On Friday, November 13, the Oregon Public Utility Commission approved Pacific Power’s new large-load tariff, closing out a yearlong argument over the question every state with a utility and an AI boom is now fighting out one docket at a time: who pays when a data center asks for 20 megawatts? The commission adopted a joint settlement in Order No. 26-443, in Docket UE 463, creating a new customer class — Schedule 401 — for facilities that use, or can use, 20 megawatts or more for computing infrastructure, data processing, web hosting, or related services. Pacific Power must file final tariff sheets by November 24, and the rules take effect January 1, 2027.

The answer Oregon gave is about as close to “the data center does” as any state has gotten. New generation or storage built to serve one of these facilities gets billed to it directly, even when that same plant also ends up serving other customers. The facility pays for the wires and poles run to reach it, and for power Pacific Power buys on the open market to cover it before new generation comes online. It must sign a long-term service agreement committing to that cost before the utility builds anything. The Citizens’ Utility Board, Oregon’s statutory ratepayer advocate, called the agreement “the strongest from a for-profit electric utility yet” under the POWER Act.

The law behind the tariff is the POWER Act, House Bill 3546, passed by the Oregon Legislature in 2025. It requires the state’s investor-owned utilities to put large data centers in their own rate class and to keep the cost of serving them from shifting onto homes and other businesses. The commission’s POWER Act legislative report estimates data-center load at roughly 15 percent of investor-owned utility load now and about 25 percent by 2030, while both PGE and Pacific Power have raised customer rates about 50 percent since 2020. The fear the Act was written against is specific: a utility builds a plant or a line for a hyperscaler, then asks regulators to let the cost flow into everyone else’s bill if the load arrives smaller or later than promised.

What the tariff actually requires

The settlement’s cost rules fall into three buckets. First, generation and storage: new data centers must cover the cost of all new generation and storage built to power them, including plants and batteries, even if those additions also benefit other customers. Second, wires: the facility pays for the transmission and distribution built for its service — the substation, the line extension, the upgrades its load triggers. Third, market power: the facility pays for energy Pacific Power buys on the market to serve it before new generation comes online. The customer also pays for the studies and the cost of negotiating its own contract. New resources serving these facilities must be non-emitting, and if fossil power serves one, the facility offsets the added emissions.

The wires bucket has a worked example, courtesy of the Citizens’ Utility Board. If a 100-megawatt transmission line is needed to serve a 50-megawatt data center as well as other residential and industrial customers, the data center pays for 50 percent of the line — its share of demand. The principle, laid out in this desk’s interconnection explainer, is cost causer pays. Oregon has written the principle into a tariff with arithmetic attached, so the argument about who caused how much of a shared upgrade has a formula instead of a hearing.

The commitment is locked in before construction, not after it. Each new facility signs an individual service contract approved by the commission, lasting 10 to 30 years, with renewals of at least 10 years — the guard against the stranded-asset outcome the POWER Act was written to stop. The contract is also the tariff’s most distinctive structural choice: Schedule 401 is direct contracting, not a stated class rate, so there is no published flat price for every developer. Each large facility gets its own commission-reviewed agreement, priced around its own cost buckets.

Then there is the 1-cent charge. Data centers of 100 megawatts or more will also pay 1 cent per kilowatt-hour into a fund for energy efficiency, critical home repairs, and small-scale energy projects for low-income Pacific Power customers in Oregon, with spending rules to be set in a separate case. The commissioners wrote that a load of 100 megawatts or more “places unique burdens on the system” that are hard to measure but real, pointing to data centers competing with everyone else for scarce clean energy projects, transmission space, transformers, and specialized labor. They matched the charge already ordered for PGE’s very large customers, in part to keep data centers from shopping between the two utilities’ territories.

The settlement nobody had to be dragged into

Most of these fights end in a split vote. Oregon’s did not need one. On September 16, Pacific Power, commission staff, the Citizens’ Utility Board, and a group of environmental intervenors represented by the Green Energy Institute at Lewis & Clark Law School filed a joint stipulation resolving every disputed issue in the docket. The commission’s November 13 order approved terms the adversaries had already negotiated between themselves, rather than terms one side imposed and the other was left to challenge afterward.

That distinction matters more than any single number in the tariff. A formula a utility wrote alone and hoped would survive a hearing is a target for the next challenge, the next legislative session, the next data center that argues its own load profile should be the exception. A formula with the ratepayer advocate’s and the environmental bar’s signatures already on it is a much harder thing to unwind. The commission rejected the objections raised and found the settlement just and reasonable — but the deal’s durability was arguably settled on September 16. Pacific Power’s framing, in its November 13 release, was affordability: “As Oregon continues to attract investment and economic development, it’s important that growth happens in a way that protects affordability for the customers we serve today,” said Rick Link, the utility’s senior vice president of planning and regulation.

How it differs from PGE’s Schedule 96

Portland General Electric got there first. The commission approved its Schedule 96 large-load tariff on May 7 under Order No. 26-154, in Docket UM 2377 — the state’s first working answer to the Act’s mandate. PGE’s new data-center rates took effect July 8, rising nearly 30 percent while residential bills declined slightly.

Pacific Power’s version goes further than PGE’s in one important respect: how the two utilities allocate the cost of new supply. Pacific Power assigns costs based on who is driving overall demand — new generation and storage built to serve a facility is billed to it directly, including plants and batteries that also help other customers. PGE assigns costs based on how much each customer class is growing and adding to the system’s highest demand periods. The methods match the systems: PGE serves the dense Portland metro; Pacific Power’s territory is rural and dispersed, where one large load can dominate a local system.

There is a second difference, and it cuts the other way. PGE’s tariff applies to future and existing data centers. Pacific Power’s applies, in the first instance, to facilities that show up from here forward — though the order reaches back in one defined case: a data center that signed with Pacific Power before June 16, 2025, falls under the new tariff if serving it requires $10 million or more in new spending after that date. The broader treatment of the large-load customers already on Pacific Power’s system goes to a later case, expected next spring.

The objections, and what the commission did with them

Not every party agreed. The Data Center Coalition, the industry group representing the hyperscalers Pacific Power is about to start billing under this framework, opposed parts of the settlement. It argued that state law requires a stated, cost-of-service rate rather than prices set in individual contracts; that the POWER Act does not let a utility shift its emissions-reduction duties onto a single customer; and that the 1-cent charge should be tied to a set program budget with annual reporting. The commission rejected those objections and found the settlement just and reasonable.

Two other parties took narrower positions. Amazon Data Services did not oppose the deal but asked for assurance that it would not encourage the utility to overbuild power plants — a utility that can bill a captive customer for new generation has less reason to build only what is needed. NewSun, a solar developer, asked for changes to how large customers get in line to connect to the grid. To address that, Pacific Power must share its data center interconnection queue with the commission in a confidential report, publish a public version, and justify any changes; its first report is due March 31, 2027. Whether the coalition appeals to the Oregon Court of Appeals is the first open question: the group has made no public statement since the order issued.

What it means for a hyperscaler pricing a site

For a developer modeling a large-load site in Pacific Power’s Oregon territory, the practical consequence is a narrow window and a different kind of quote. Pacific Power must file revised tariff language by November 24, and the new rules take effect January 1, 2027. There is no published rate to plug into a model. There is a contract to negotiate, with the commission reviewing it, and a 10-to-30-year commitment attached — priced around the three cost buckets, generation and storage, wires, and market power, rather than folded into one blended rate.

That changes the site-selection arithmetic in two directions at once. On one hand, Oregon just became more expensive for a new large load than a state where the utility socializes upgrade costs across its rate base — which is to say, most states. On the other hand, Oregon just became more predictable in the way that matters to a project with a 10-year horizon: the rules are written, the ratepayer advocate signed them, the environmental intervenors signed them, and the commission approved them. The alternative in many states is a rate case that has not happened yet.

The national template

The reason this order will be read outside Oregon is that the “who pays” fight is now being settled state by state in tariffs, and Oregon’s version is the toughest template so far. The federal route closed, at least for now, on October 9, when the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission rejected most of PJM’s plan to make new data centers bring their own capacity or face curtailment first in emergencies, throwing out the bring-your-own-new-capacity provisions as reaching into retail policy reserved to the states. The states are where the cost allocation gets decided, one tariff at a time.

Oregon’s answer has a feature the other templates lack, and it is the one other states will find hardest to copy: it was negotiated before it was imposed. Florida’s Public Service Commission rejected Duke Energy’s first large-load tariff 5-0 after the utility’s own lawyers wrote a narrower definition than the statute allowed — the cautionary tale of a utility drafting alone. Oregon’s commission approved a deal its staff, its ratepayer advocate, and its environmental intervenors had already signed. Whatever the Data Center Coalition does with an appeal, it is arguing against a deal the state’s consumer watchdog already put its name on.

That durability is the template’s real export. Other commissions watching Oregon will see two things: a cost-allocation design that bills the causer for generation, wires, and market power, with a community benefits charge for the largest loads — and a process design in which the settlement comes first and the vote ratifies it. The first is copyable by any state with a statute like the POWER Act. The second requires a ratepayer advocate willing to negotiate rather than litigate, and a utility willing to give the advocate a real signature.

What to watch

Four dates and one decision will tell whether this order holds. November 24, when Pacific Power files the final tariff sheets — the language that turns Order No. 26-443 into Schedule 401. January 1, 2027, when the rules take effect and the first new facility signs a contract under them. March 31, 2027, when Pacific Power’s first program report and its interconnection queue disclosure are due. And the separate case that will set the rules for spending the 1-cent community benefits charge.

The decision is the appeal. If the Data Center Coalition challenges the order in the Oregon Court of Appeals, the fight will be over direct contracting itself: whether a statute that requires a rate class permits prices set in individual commission-reviewed contracts. If no appeal comes, the tariff becomes the settled law of Pacific Power’s territory on January 1, and the spring case on existing large-load customers becomes the live fight. Either way, the direction is set: Oregon has now written, twice, that a data center pays for the power system it causes. The second version is the stronger one, and the rest of the country is reading it.