On Monday, November 16, the California Independent System Operator filed its answer to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s June 18 large-load show-cause order, in docket ER27-532. The framework itself was no surprise: the CAISO Board of Governors approved it on October 28, and this desk covered it on November 5. What the filing adds is the part the board package only sketched — the operating rules a 50-megawatt load will actually have to live by, the metering treatment that decides what it pays for grid services, and the division of labor between the CAISO tariff and the three big utilities’ tariffs, where the cost question now sits.
That effective date sets the clock for everything else. February 16 is 92 days after the filing — the CAISO notes February 14 falls on a weekend and February 15 is a federal holiday. Two technology-dependent pieces would come later: scheduling-coordinator requirements on November 1, 2027, and settlements provisions on April 30, 2028. Nothing in the filing is a rule yet; FERC has not acted on it.
The operating rules are the filing
The filing’s most consequential new material is a set of operating requirements for large loads, developed through the CAISO’s Large Load Technical Requirements Working Group and written into proposed tariff section 25.7.1. These are the rules that answer the July 22 event in Northern Virginia, when a normally cleared fault triggered the loss of nearly 3,900 megawatts of data center load — and the parallel NERC standards package, approved on final ballot in mid-October, which sets no industry-wide minimum ride-through requirement.
Before any large load energizes, its participating transmission owner must give the CAISO the load’s type and flat-or-variable designation, expected hourly operating profile, points of interconnection and withdrawal, megawatt capacity, and minimum and maximum operating levels. The owner must also ensure the load has continuous dynamic disturbance recording on the high side of its main power transformer — per-phase voltages and currents, real and reactive power, and frequency — so the next disturbance leaves a record instead of a mystery. And the owner must be able to disconnect or isolate the load in a contingency or emergency.
The filing then imposes ride-through requirements, modeled on the rules that already apply to generating facilities: a large load must stay connected through specified frequency and voltage disturbances. One provision resolves an ambiguity before it can become a dispute — a load-shedding program or remedial action scheme directed by the CAISO or the transmission owner takes precedence over the ride-through obligation, so a load is never caught between two conflicting instructions to stay on and to trip off.
Twenty megawatts a minute, ninety percent in three seconds
The numbers that will matter most to data center operators are the ramp and recovery limits. During normal operation — including startup, shutdown, routine changes, and restoration after outages — a large load’s average active-power ramp rate, measured at the point of interconnection over a rolling ten-minute interval, may not exceed 20 megawatts per minute, in either direction. That is a real constraint on a facility whose computing load can swing by hundreds of megawatts as training jobs start and stop. After a system fault, the load must restore consumption to at least 90 percent of its pre-disturbance level within three seconds once voltage recovers to at least 0.90 per unit.
On top of that, the scheduling coordinator representing the load must supply daily and hourly forecast data, flag any real-time material deviation — energization activity, operational changes, curtailments, outages, derates, or co-located generation effects — and provide operational status and real-time consumption through direct telemetry. After any disturbance involving a large load, the load, its interconnection customer, its scheduling coordinator, and the transmission owner must comply with any data request from the CAISO, the regional entity, or the Reliability Coordinator.
The definition, and what it deliberately leaves out
The filed definition is spare: a large load is an end user at a single site, behind one or more points of interconnection to the CAISO Controlled Grid, with a peak load of 50 megawatts or greater. Three omissions are deliberate. It sets no voltage level, because “CAISO Controlled Grid” already requires evaluation under the Commission’s transmission-versus-distribution tests. It does not exclude co-located loads. And it does not use the word “new,” because that would require its own specification.
Instead of “new,” the filing grandfathers by date. A load that is operational, or that has a complete request with its transmission owner before the February 16, 2027 effective date, is not a large load under the CAISO tariff — unless it later increases or modifies its load, at which point it becomes one, under criteria the transmission owners will set in their own tariffs.
The study clock, and who actually studies
The study process follows the division of responsibility that has defined California’s answer from the start: the participating transmission owners receive and perform the load interconnection studies, and the CAISO reviews them. The filing expects the owners to develop consistent study procedures finishing within 60 to 90 days, the window FERC suggested, and the CAISO will review on a monthly basis so its check does not push the owners past 90 days.
The filing also writes large loads into transmission planning: planning will consider large-load growth and upgrades planned as transmission solutions for public policies under the Order No. 1000 process, including grid-enhancing technologies such as advanced conductors and dynamic line ratings. On transparency, the CAISO proposes to publicly post aggregate proposed large-load additions by transmission pricing zone, the planned network upgrades needed for each transmission service request, and cost estimates for each.
No new market model
One thing the filing does not do is create a new way for large loads to participate in the CAISO markets. Instead, a large load may participate as an ordinary end user represented by its load-serving entity, or through any existing model — proxy demand resource, reliability demand response resource, participating load, non-generator resource — alone or in aggregation.
Who pays: the answer lives in the owners’ tariffs
The cost question — the one that matters most to existing customers — is where the CAISO filing is most candid about its limits. The CAISO does not propose a top-down cost allocation solution in its own tariff. It says that work belongs in the transmission owners’ tariffs, because the owners build and own the network upgrades, hold the direct relationship with retail ratepayers, and answer to the California Public Utilities Commission on the rates those customers ultimately pay.
Southern California Edison’s filing, docket ER27-508, proposes standardized reliability agreements and flexible interim service, with cost protections including upgrade-cost security, a 15-year minimum revenue obligation backed by five years of security for broader shared network costs, and withdrawal and exit fees. Pacific Gas and Electric’s filing, docket ER27-513, would implement a process for transmission customers to interconnect large-load end users — against a data-center pipeline PG&E reports at roughly 12.9 gigawatts, according to a Latitude Media analysis of the filings. San Diego Gas & Electric proposes a large-load definition that does not exclude co-located loads, rolling applications, a non-refundable application fee, and limited operation pending upgrades. The CAISO says the owners are leading development of the pro forma cost recovery agreement FERC keeps returning to — backed by financial security, obliging the load to cover the costs incurred to serve it, even if the project is canceled or runs below its anticipated demand.
The netting fight, settled two ways
On co-location, the filing splits the difference in a way that reflects how differently California’s charges work from PJM’s. For ancillary services, the CAISO concedes the point: it will require transmission owners to sub-meter each co-located large load independently of any on-site generation, and scheduling coordinators must report those meter values separately, so each large load pays regulation, black start, and reliability services costs on its gross demand rather than netting its own generation against it.
On transmission access charges, the CAISO holds the line and defends the status quo. FERC had preliminarily found that allowing behind-the-meter generation to be netted against gross load — the billing determinant for the Regional Access Charge — may be unjust and unreasonable, drawing on its PJM co-location order. The CAISO’s answer is that PJM’s charges are assessed on peak demand, which a load can mask by generating during the peak hour, while CAISO’s access charges are assessed 24 hours a day, 365 days a year on gross load. Netting against the access charge stays; netting against ancillary service charges goes.
The co-location rules around it are largely clarifications of the status quo. Backup-only and non-exporting behind-the-meter generation need no CAISO study and can interconnect through the utilities’ Rule 21 process. Generation that exports to the grid must complete a CAISO interconnection study, with results reflecting the combined operation of load and generation. And the filing draws a hard line on storage: wholesale energy storage co-located with a large load must be metered separately and cannot be commingled with the load.
FILI as filed: bespoke, uncapped, and public
The Flexible Interim Load Interconnection service — FILI — arrives in the filing as the board approved it, with two details that sharpen the picture. First, the CAISO expressly declines to put any temporal or capacity cap on the service, arguing that each arrangement is bespoke to its point of interconnection and constraints. Second, the service can be delivered through remedial action schemes, enforceable operating requirements, or a preset schedule, with automated schemes or owner-performed curtailment limited by transmission overload under N-1-1 conditions.
Before energization, the CAISO, the transmission owner, and the load must execute an agreement specifying the circumstances in which the load may be curtailed, the mechanism, the responsible entity, notification method, response time, duration, restoration, testing, and verification, and the network upgrades required to conclude the service. The CAISO will post those agreements on its website and account for FILI loads in its base case, full network model, and operating procedures.
What the filing declines to do
The filing’s most revealing passages are the ones where the CAISO explains what it is not proposing. It will not create new Order No. 888 transmission services for flexible loads, arguing that redesigning transmission and interconnection service entirely is unwarranted. FILI is an interconnection service, not a transmission service — a distinction that matters, because the Commission rejected PJM’s Interim Resource Adequacy Service in October for crossing into retail curtailment territory.
A permanent flexible service — FLIP, floated in an August straw proposal and dropped from the draft final — is deferred to a stakeholder initiative expected to commence in 2027, which would let loads forgo some network upgrades altogether by accepting flexible service in perpetuity. Arrangements for electrically proximate generation, where a load sits a substation or two from a generator, are likewise deferred to an early-2027 initiative; stakeholders agreed they are not a near-term priority. The filing also notes the CAISO imposes no bring-your-own-generation requirement, unlike the eastern markets.
What it means for the West
For developers, the filed package changes the California site question in a specific way. The 50-megawatt line, the 60-to-90-day study window, and the interim service were already known from the board vote. What the filing adds is the operating burden: a ramp cap of 20 megawatts per minute, ride-through and three-second recovery obligations, disturbance recording, hourly forecasts, and telemetry — plus the need to negotiate a bespoke, publicly posted curtailment agreement before energizing under FILI. A facility that can pause gains real value from that bargain; one that cannot tolerate interruption still waits for its upgrades. The scale is large: the California Energy Commission forecasts data center load on the CAISO-managed grid growing by 1.8 gigawatts by 2030 and 4.7 gigawatts by 2035.
For existing customers, the filing will be judged on the half of the answer it does not contain. The cost protections — the deposits, the security, the 15-year revenue obligation in Edison’s filing, the exit fees — live in the owners’ tariffs, and the pro forma cost recovery agreement is still being developed by the owners rather than filed. The CAISO’s transparency commitments help, but the mechanism only works if the owners’ terms actually bind a load that shrinks, delays, or disappears after the wires are built.
What to watch
Three things will determine whether ER27-532 becomes a working tariff. The first is the comment period, running to mid-December: the missing permanent service, the uncapped interim service, the 60-to-90-day study clock, and the owners’ cost terms are the joints stakeholders will test, and Constellation Energy has already urged the board to include a permanent flexible option in the filing. The second is FERC’s disposition — accept, accept subject to condition, set for hearing, or prescribe a remedy. The third is operational: the first FILI customer. An interim service exists on paper until a load actually connects under it, is curtailed under it, and converts to firm service when its upgrades finish.